The archetype of the Orc is perhaps most well known today as the primary foil for the heroes of the series Lord of the Rings as well as many Dungeon and Dragons campaigns. The Orcs, just as the other factions discussed in this series have had a history of being portrayed as villains and monsters, obstacles to be dispatched by various heroes and forces of good.

Introduction

The Orcs of the Warcraft world is described as warlike and proud, living a life of conflict and warfare. The Orcs of the warcraft world live for the honor of their clan and their name, and will rather die than to lose either. The influences of war and combat can be seen in most depictions of their culture and traditions, from the titles of their leaders, to the layout and construction of their buildings (Blizzard 2012).

The comparison between Orcs in warcraft and certain stereotypes relating to African natives is a topic that is very well handled in the text by Spiecker (2011). I will in this text primarily focus on the Orc as an expression of the other. Here the Orc will be positioned against the more westernized human. This dichotomy is something that has existed since the series inception. The humans always presented as logical, civilized and faithful. The Orcs, and later the hoard being their opposite of vilient, illogical and savage.

The other

The Other is one way of describing the object of the self, is to relate it to, or contrast it with something outside of the self. This outside force or individual is known as the other, and by defining the other, the individual can use said outer to describe what they are not. This sense of otherness can be used to draw lines between, secualities, nationalities religions and cultures. Otherness can furthermore be related to individuals, as well as to groups of people, be them companies, religions or nation states.

I will primarily use the other to discuss race, and nationality, but also religion and politics to some extent. The other has been used to describe the underlying motivational forces, and justifications for western colonialism, where the western white and supposedly enlightened race was set against the so called savage and wild African and later Native American nations. By describing what the European explorers saw as wild, savage and uneducated, they could place themselves as cultured, logical and educated. The Others were creatures of wars, cannibalism and brutality while the Europeans represented peace, enlightenment and prosperity. The process of describing the west by a perceived other is what  is in academic circles often described as Orientalism. (Mountz 2016)

The otherness of the Horde

I have described in earlier chapters how culture and religion has been used to present some of the members of the hordes as stereotypically “non European”, starkly contrasted to the eurocentric Alliance. The same sort of tropes that were used by Europeans to describe the other is present within the Horde, and within the Orcs in particular. Characteristics such as violence, superstition and “primitive” craftsmanship are all things that make out the visual language of the Orcs and the Horde as a whole.

Due to the Orcs and the Humans being the most fleshed out factions, being the only ones playable in all three original games, it does make sense that these factions, more than the rest, color the visual language of the games. It is not a far stretch to imagine that the human is meant to be considered the protagonist of the series, seeing that the writers, as well as the players are indeed human. As mentioned before, human architecture and cultures borrow heavily from western medieval costumes and architecture, something that’s made even more apparent when taken in account the witness of all of the major human characters’ skin.

One source of the creative decision of the Warcraft series comes from its original inspiration, Warhammer Fantasy. A series that is set in a fantasy version of Europe during the late medieval period,, Indeed most continents are present in the Warhammer Fantasy world, but with a large focus on Europe or “the old world”. Warhammer fantasy is a series I will return to later on.

Orcs are, as discussed earlier, often used as the typical antagonist in modern fantasy, a brutal warlike evil that can be set against the heroes and can be dispatched with impunity. While Warcraft, especially Warcraft 3 goes out of its way to humanize the Orcs and give them more redeeming qualities throughout the campaign, they still represent a society of war and strict hiercies. Where the humans have kings and ministers, the Orcs have warchiefs and warlords. Instead of building citides, they create war camps and forts. Each thing the Orcs create seems to be geared towards violence and aggression.

While the human faction also has soldiers, and fought in wars, it is not described to be so integral and tied to their culture and way of life. While not necessarily the intentions of the creators, this distinction nonetheless points towards a trend in western fantasy of the era. By tying certain cultural traits and tropes to the human factions, the text creates a link between certain culture, and humanity.

The image of the Orcs supposed savage nature is driven home by their architecture. Their buildings use bones and leather, giving them a more “primitive” look, when placed next to the human versions of the same buildings. The human buildings are mundane town houses and straw roofed hamplets. The orc houses are in comparison made out of stone and spiked poles, clearly made to be defensive structures. Even the seemingly civilian wood cutting structure of the Orcs is known as a War mill, further defining the Orc culture as one with a focus on martial traditions.

This dichotomy can most clearly be seen in buildings that create spellcasters. The Horde has a tent that brings to the imagination northern native american tribes. The human arcane sanctum that draws the imagination to alchemists and astronomers, with astrological devices and strange glowing runes. This distinction can be found in the units these buildings create as well. Where the humans have sorceresses and priests, the Orcs have shamans and witch doctors. Terms that I have discussed earlier in this series, but that rings of a clear Western and Non-western theme.

Conclusions

Throughout this series, I have used the trilogy of Warcraft to discuss the concepts of otherness when it pertains to race, faith and culture. In this final chapter I have discussed how the use of war and warlike traditions is used to differentiate between the more civilized Humans, and the savage Orcs. This destinction is one that has been used several time in human history to justify slavery and conquests. The example I have chosen in this chapter is the European colonisations of so-called “less civilized people and nations”. I hope to show with this comparison that no piece of media is made in a vacuum, and we are always colored by what came before us. But by becoming aware of this history, can we make more active and informed decisions of what kind of stories we wish to tell, and listen to in the future.

This series was made primarily to show that pop culture can be a great way to explore the people, societies and cultures that created it. It can help us understand ourselves and others, and our place in the bigger context of the societies we find ourselves living within.

Introduction

In the previous chapter of this series, did we get a glimpse on what in Anthropology for many years has been known as the “noble savage”. The so-called others that the European explorers encountered, individuals and communities though seen as other, and in many cases lesser, they were still seen as “good”, and in some cases even better then the corrupt western mind, due to their supposed simplicity and purity. In this chapter we will take a look at the other side of the image of the supposed savage, the one that did not get the western approval, and we will do this via the lenses of the modern troll in contemporary fantasy literature.

Voodoo, Vodou and the western narrative

The concept of Voodoo as it most commonly known in western popular culture is more often than not framed as something evil and or foreboding, strange and othering. Famous examples are the evil powers used by James Bond villains in Live and Let Die (1973) as well as the villains of Indiana Jones and the Temple of doom (1984). Similar negative and villainous portrayals can be found in many contemporary and later mainstream and pulp representations of Voodoo in western media. Common tropes of these representations are its focus on the otherness, exoticism and danger of the practice, as well as the fact that the practice is rarely, if ever described at its own terms. The first known example of horror films is the first Zombie movie, White zombie. Many examples of the negative stereotypes of Voodoo can be found in this movie, from exostisism, human sacrifice as well as snakes and skulls.

Just like with the chapter on the Tauren must I here reiterate that I am far from knowledgeable about the actual Just like with the chapter on the Tauren must I here reiterate that I am far from knowledgeable about the actual practices of Voodoo, or more specifically Vodou, or any adjacent faith structures, and I in no way claim to be. Keep this in mind however I discuss these practices in this and following texts. As a result will I in this text purely focus on how the depiction of the Trolls can be tied to tropes and stereotypes found in other western media regarding the views and stereotypes about Voodoo amongst its creators and audience.

Voodoo dolls, spirits and witch doctors are all terms that are common in the descriptions of Voodoo in popular western fiction, though rarely, if ever are they used in their indented contexts or meaning. Note that there are indeed exceptions to this rule, particularly in later years, but at the time of the release of warcraft 3 was Voodoo firmly in the realm of “strange otherness” for the vast majority of western audiences. Commuting with spirits, and the use of dolls to hurt and control victims are similarly very popular themes that seem to return several times in western media depicting the practice of Voodoo.

The savage, cannibal and the rebel

In the last chapter did we use the text of Ellingson (2001) to describe the more “benign” aspect of what has come to be known as the noble savage. This chapter will discuss the other side of that trope. Namely the people that the travailing anthropologists did not look at as favourably. Chief amongst these persevere traits were the concept of cannibalism, be it real or imagined by the western observer.

What is important for this chapter is that Haitian cultures and societies, during various points in history, have been tied, by western observers, to the practice of cannibalism as a way of lessening their worth as human beings. Ellingson (2001) further explains that in areas where cannibalism seems to be lacking, other atrocities such as mutilation or sacrifice of war prisoners could be used in its place, that way practically any “savage” could be tied to cannibalism by proxy.

The concept of alienation and savagery can easily be found in the direct connection to Voodoo, or Vodou as it is officially recognized, both in the Haitian and New Orleans incarnations. To truly understand the depth and importance of Voodoo for these areas, we must first discuss the Haitian revolution, and so many in the white western world (including me), have not thought about it. (Reinhardt, 2020)

Between the years of 1791 and 1804 did the former colony known today Haiti, carried out a successful revolt against their French colonial rulers, though many readers, just as myself, were probably not aware of this fact until now. The historian Reinhardt argues in his text, that the concept of a black revolt would be unthinkable for the contemporary white mind, slaves could run away, yes, they could kill their masters surely, but the concept of a black lead revolt was impossible to imagine, even less so a successful one. (Reinhardt, 2020)

This revolution is tightly linked to the Haitian Vodou faith and practices. A Vodou ceremony was in fact the place of the beginning of this rebellion. Furthermore is the practice of Voodoo, both in Haiti, and later the New Orleans branch, both clear examples of rebellion against colonial and racist powers imposed on their predominantly black practitioners. (Tussaint-strauss, 2020, Fandrich 2007)

Trolls in modern fantasy

The troll in modern fantasy, has as many other concepts, much of its roots to be found in J.R.R Tolkien’s massive works, as well as Germanic myths and legends. The modern troll is often described as strong, dumb, cruel and with a love for eating other sentient creatures, mainly human beings. A popular trope is furthermore that trolls are infamously difficult to damage with anything other then fire, due to their abnormal power of healing.

The modern Trolls serve descriptions and narrative uses within the fictions that they are depicted in. What matters for this text is that the troll, just as Orcs, Goblins and other monstrous creatures is almost always, if not exclusively presented as the other, the evil and the monstrous. Rarely, if ever, are these creatures pictured in a sympathetic or positive light.

Note that these creatures are physically humanoid, though always different, in often strange and grotesque ways. The most common version of the troll that we find in modern fantasy mirrors the versions found in Scandinavian folklore, as well as their reimagining in Tolkien’s mythos.

Trolls in warcraft 3

The version of the trolls we find in warcraft 3 follows many of the popular tropes discussed above. They are often the version of the trolls we find in warcraft 3 follows many of the popular tropes discussed above. They are often described as a cruel and sadistic race, taking pleasure in the pain they cause, they are furthermore very dangerous to kill off due to their ability to regenerate from what should be mortal wounds. Lastly have they been shown to have no problem in consuming other sentient races, as well as other trolls, this feature is so integral that they were given an ability to do so in the MMORPG World of warcraft, enabling the player to eat the corpses of defeated foes.

Many of the same terms and concepts that permeate contemporary western pop culture regarding Vodou can be found amongst the descriptions of the Warcraft 3 trolls. The most prominent and easily recognisable features being that one of their main military units, pictured above is known as the Witch Doctor. Furthermore are upgrades for Troll units found in a building known as the Voodoo lounge.

Many of the voice-lines of the troll characters make further references to stereotypical Voodoo related practices such as communing with spirits as well as mentioning good and bad mojo. Furthermore, do the two primary Troll units within the game, the witch doctor and the headhunter both use abilities that refer to the practices described above. The term headhunter hints at the soteriological Voodoo practice of gathering and shrinking enemies heads, while the term witch doctor is tightly tied to Voodoo and Vodou in the western imagination.

Like many other versions of the Troll in fantasy, are they depicted as more monstrous versions of the humanoid form, being tall, with enormous ears and noses. The troll is furthermore given a more bestial visage with the addition of two large tusks protruding from their face. Their alienation is made further with their blue skin tones, a trend that will continue with the Orcs. This visual can once again be prepared to the much more traditionally attractive human forms in the shapes of Humans, Elves and Dwarves respectively.

Conclusions

Once again have we seen that the creative design of Warcraft 3 shows their inspirations on its sleeves, for better or worse. the use of Vodou practices is in and of itself not the problem, but the combination of Vodou, and other Once again have we seen that the creative design of Warcraft 3 shows their inspirations on its sleeves, for better or worse. the use of Vodou practices is in and of itself not the problem, but the combination of Vodou, and other stereotypically negative “savage” tropes such as cannibalism does point at negative underlying stereotypes. This image of otherness amongst the trolls, is furthered the tropes of Vodou as well as negative “savage” tropes is given to a stereotypically monstrous race, the troll. The sensation of otherness is made quite clear when put in contrast with the human faction, that is not only predominantly shown to be white, but is also heavily coded as western and Christian in their presentation.

Just as the Tauren depiction seen in the last chapter, is the Trolls part of a wider system of tying Vodou and similar non white practices to cannibalism and other forms of brutal and savage traditions. As I have shown in this chapter is it not uncommon a trend can be found in the depictions of Vodou as evil or savage magic. The practice of condemning a foreign practice of religious philosophy, is one way of legitimizing your own as True faith. A practice that is, even though made subconsciously, continued in the text of Warcraft 3.

The choice to give the traits of traditionally coded Haitian Vodou practices to a monstrous races can not be understated, as well as the depiction of the Horde in general as a more bestial and primitive race, something that we will discuss further in the upcoming chapter on orcs can not be understated. Regardless of what the intention of this division was at the creation of the text, is it not possible to ignore the fact that it exists a stark contrast between the two major forces of the Horde and the Alliance, one having a distinctly western and “progressive” coding, while the other having a similarly distinct foreign and “savage coding. Note that foreign is here used to denote otherness, in this case, individuals other than the western culture and traditions.

The goal of this series is not to try and condemn and shame. My goal is to show how unchallenged tropes and subconscious biases can help produce hateful and derogatory depictions in the media we create. It is difficult to become aware of once biases and underlying narrative tropes without having them pointed out to you. It is my goal in this series to provide some examples of such biases and tropes to the reader, in the hopes of helping them discover their own biases, and if they choose, overcome them. While becoming aware of, and being able to reflect critically about these biases, will we be able to more inclusive, imaginative and engaging narratives in the future.

Sources

llingson, T. (2001). The myth of the noble savage. Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press.

Reinhardt, T. (2005). 200 Years of Forgetting: Hushing up the Haitian Revolution. Journal of Black Studies, 35(4), 246-261. Retrieved September 13, 2021, from http://www.jstor.org/stable/40027220

Toussaint-strauss, Josh (2020) How ‘voodoo’ became a metaphor for evil, YouTube series

Zarka, E. (2020) The Origins of the Zombie, from Haiti to the U.S. | Monstrum YouTube series

Ramsey, K. (2012). From ‘Voodooism’ to ‘Vodou’: Changing a US Library of Congress Subject Heading. Journal of Haitian Studies, 18(2), 14-25. Retrieved September 13, 2021, from http://www.jstor.org/stable/41949200

Fandrich, I. (2007). Yorùbá Influences on Haitian Vodou and New Orleans Voodoo. Journal of Black Studies, 37(5), 775-791. Retrieved September 13, 2021, from http://www.jstor.org/stable/40034365