I have previously written about the importance of in game stories and nonfiction books in world building and storytelling, especially when it comes to fantasy and sci fi. In this text I wish to go even more granular and discuss a genre that is close to my heart, the essay. Often more loose in form than a report or a paper, essays are great for presenting ideas and concepts in a condensed yet easy to understand format.
Essays often exclude some of the contexts needed to understand the texts if it’s common knowledge. This allows the text to focus more on the topic at hand. This makes essays uniquely suited to give a player tidbits about the world a game is set in, without needing to present a lot of information all at once. Essays allow you to bring small packets of information in a condensed format. It allows the player to put together the information themselves over the length of the game’s narrative.
Essays have a further advantage of having a more personal voice in its writing. This allows you to not only tell stories with the essay itself, but also be able to create a writer of essays. A person that allows for a unique point of view. It is this point of view character that makes the essay such a vital tool of narratives.
The Elder scrolls series is no stranger to in-universe texts, some have gotten physical releases as well. Elder scrolls has several texts that not only discusses parts of the world, but argues for or against certain assumptions of the narrative. For example, the many schools of magic are hotly debated in a number of texts. Necromancy in particular is debated and arguments for and against.
Likewise many historical events of the narrative are discussed in great length. In this text I would like to discuss two such texts in particular. The life of Barenziah and the mystery of the Dwemer. Both are excellent examples on how elder scrolls play with the idea of an objective reality in its narrative.
Dwemer, myths and misinformation
The disappearance of the Dwemer is described as one of the largest mysteries in the narrative of The Elder Scrolls. Their obsession with science, their alien philosophy and of course their sudden disappearance from Nirn all together have fueled discussions both in game and amongst fans. There are many texts discussing and arguing the minutiae of Dwemer, science and beliefs. Some texts like On Dwemer law and the Dwemer series are written as serious scholarly attempts to try and get to the bottom of Dwemer culture, and what impact they have had on Dunmer and Altmer culture.
There is also the series of Ancient Tales of the Dwemer. That presents the Dwemer in a very different light. The Dwemer described in these tables are considerably kinder, more peaceful and overall friendly than the Dwemer that can be found in other texts.
This discrepancy is something the players will find for themselves when devling into the many Dwemer dungeons and facing the many sadistic traps and torture chambers of the old Dwemer holds.
This is a point that the scholar Hasphat Antabolis discusses in his text Dwemer History and Culture. He argues that the tales discussed in the Ancient Tales of the Dwemer are in fact re-packaged folk tales that have been rewritten to be given a certain exotic Dwemer flair.
That the kind and friendly Dwemer became a lot more palatable for the middle class reading rooms. These texts have as a result been spread and read by thousands, and are today still very prominent, despite the fact that they have been thoroughly debunked. The idea of a historical narrative remaining true even after decades of disproving is something that can be found in many places in real life.
The text brings up ideas of how dark and brutal histories and cultures can often be softened and simplified in order to make them more palatable to the general public. This is a wonderful example of how Skyrim uses real life phenomena within history and anthropological research to make its game world feel more complex.
The life of Barenziah and Biography of Barenziah
The controversial character of Barenziah has two texts written about her. One official series of biographies titled Biography of Barenziah paints her as the first and only Dunmer empress and describes the struggles of her life with a kind and borderline naive tone, breathlessly praising her numerous grand qualities. The second unofficial text written by an anonymous scribe titled The Real Barenziah is scandalous, provocative and deeply judgmental with poorly hidden sexism and racism contained through the text. The role of Straw the stable boy is one of the decisive differences.
What is interesting about these texts is the transparent intent of the authors behind both series. One series is describing in short and somewhat dry terms the life of the only Dunmer ruler of the empire. The other is a series of character assassinations and brutal accusations of promiscuity and debasement. Sadly this is a tactic that has, and still is used to discredit many women who have been in power. Furthermore, the first text is written as a simple document that retells major events in Barenziah life, while the second is written like a serialized romance novel, with rich descriptions of events and lengthy dialogues.
The stark difference in the texts presented narrative forces the player to look at this one historical figure from separate points of view. While the text of Skyrim makes it clear in the presentation of the texts which one is the more probable and reliable. It does nonetheless make a clear case that not every text that the player encounters can or should be trusted. Like in real life are all narratives created by a person, a person with a specific worldview, historical background and motivations. Both texts have clear biases, and both have clear goals with their narratives. It is up to the player what parts to believe.
Final thoughts
I like to conclude this essay by discussing another series, Rising threat, a series describing the rise of the Thalmer from an Altmer point of view. It is interesting for several reasons, one of them being the only purely Altmer narrative in the game, as well as for giving well needed context to the rise of the organization. This series explains how the Thalmer monopolized the sudden end to the Oblivion crisis, and claimed that they were the true heroes of the calamity.
Despite this falsehood eventually being disproven, has it nonetheless become a truism within the history of the Altmer. Furthermore, the texts are interesting for the disclaimer made by Praxis Erratuim that warns the reader not to take some of the more fanciful speculations of the texts all too seriously. Like with the Anecdotes of the Dwemer this text presents the idea that history is sometimes not created by the most reliable facts, but by the most prevailing of narratives.
My goal with this text is to present my reader with a few examples in how ambiguity and contradictions can be used to deepen a narrative and make a fictional world feel more complex, more nuanced and more alive. I would also like to argue for the use of books and journals for the furtherance of narratives and lore that would be unwieldy to present in direct or ambient dialogues.With all this said, this kind of narrative presentation has some serious shortfalls. The chief being that the player needs to first find, and then read the text to get the information needed. I will discuss a few of these pitfalls in a future Skyrim essay: Books and magical excavations.
An Unused Frequency 